A Sandwich a Day: Pulled Pork Sandwich at The Smoke Daddy

A Sandwich a Day

Reviews of Chicago sandwiches.


[Photograph: Josh Conley]

It always kills me when a barbecue joint will spend 15 hours guiding a pork shoulder from porcine purgatory right up to the gates of barbecue heaven, only to spend five seconds deciding to plop it on a dry sesame seed bun. Barbecue is still subject to the sandwich sum-of-its-parts law, and no place heeds this like the pulled pork sandwich ($11.50 w/1 side), Carolina and Daddy style, at The Smoke Daddy.

First, the bun conundrum solved: a golden, fresh brioche bun reinforced with a toasty barrier to hold up to the toppings. That goodness starts with a heap of pulled pork and the "Daddy" addition of a smattering of brisket. This newly-fused wondermeat is uber-tender, but with texture and chew. Next up is the "Carolina" portion of the show—a light, crunchy slaw fortified with fresh cilantro. Finally, the sauce. A great sauce enhances, a bad one smothers. All three of Smoke Daddy's sauces are excellent, but the tangy spice of the cumin-heavy, apple cider vinegar-based original is like the bow on this indulgent present. Happy Anyday to me!

The Smoke Daddy

1804 West Division Street, Chicago, IL 60622 (map)

Serious Eats Newsletters

Keep up with our latest recipes, tips, techniques and where to eat!


Comments can take up to a minute to appear - please be patient!

Previewing your comment: