Whether you prefer Southern-style or not, Chicago has no shortage of great fried chicken options. But a great fried chicken sandwich requires a little more forethought. Which brings me to Logan Square's Reno, a place I've written about a few times now. And yes, Joe already covered the Hook, the restaurant's play on a bagel with lox. But, I mean, just look at this thing! What a beautiful fried chicken sandwich. Hopefully, you'll forgive me.
Okay, with that out of the way, let's really dig into the Pine ($7.50). The thick boneless thigh gets a crispy coating, making it sturdy enough to withstand the flavorful topping assault. Tossed on a grilled trinity bun, it's blanketed with white cheddar, topped with dill pickles, and drizzled with hot honey sauce. What's fascinating is that this creamy-acidic-spicy-sweet mix still never gets in the way of the juicy crunch of the well seasoned chicken. Instead, the toppings function like an intricate Beach Boys harmony: unquestionably awesome, but nowhere near as powerful without the the melody. So, in this example, the fried chicken thigh equals Brian Wilson.
This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Serious Eats. Read more about our affiliate linking policy.